
In Miller Estate v. Arguelles, 2026 ONCA 518, released in July 2026, the Court of Appeal for Ontario set aside an eviction for a landlord’s own use that the Landlord and Tenant Board and the Divisional Court had upheld.
What happened
A landlord served N12 notices so that her daughter could move into the unit. Her son filed the L2 application, and the landlord died before the hearing. The Board amended the application to name her estate, even though no estate representative had been appointed, and ended the tenancy.
What the Court decided
- The landlord’s death before the tenancy ended invalidated the N12. Neither her son nor the estate met the requirements of section 48 of the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006 to rely on it.
- The application did not disclose an earlier N12 served on the tenant, as section 71.1 requires. This was a mandatory defect that the Board could not fix by amending the application at the hearing.
What this means for you
- Landlords: include every N12 you served with your application, and make sure the person applying is the one entitled to rely on the notice.
- Tenants: check an eviction application carefully. Defects in the notice or the application can defeat it.
We represent landlords and tenants at the Landlord and Tenant Board in Windsor and across Ontario. Learn about our LTB services or call (519) 999-9925.
Sources: Court of Appeal for Ontario, Miller Estate v. Arguelles, 2026 ONCA 518; Ontario Bar Association, Court of Appeal Summaries (July 13–17, 2026); ACTO media release.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Reviewed November 16, 2026.
بالعربية: محكمة الاستئناف تلغي إخلاءً لسكن المالك بسبب أخطاء في الطلب
في قضية Miller Estate v. Arguelles، 2026 ONCA 518، ألغت محكمة الاستئناف في أونتاريو قرار إخلاء لسكن المالك كان مجلس الملاك والمستأجرين قد وافق عليه.
- سلّمت المالكة إشعارات N12 لتسكن ابنتها في الوحدة، ثم توفيت قبل الجلسة. قضت المحكمة بأن وفاتها أبطلت الإشعار، وأن ابنها والتركة لا يحق لهما الاعتماد عليه.
- لم يتضمن الطلب إشعار N12 سابقاً سُلّم للمستأجرة، وهذا شرط إلزامي لا يستطيع المجلس تصحيحه أثناء الجلسة.
- للملاك: أرفق كل الإشعارات التي سلّمتها مع الطلب. للمستأجرين: الأخطاء في الإشعار أو الطلب قد تؤدي إلى رفض الإخلاء.
نمثّل الملاك والمستأجرين أمام مجلس الملاك والمستأجرين. احجز موعد أو اتصل على 519-999-9925.